What Can You Do With the Well on a Black Forest or Monument Property?

Horses, gardens, a guest house: read the permit before you fall for the acreage

The short answer: the well permit decides what the water can be used for, not the size of the lot or the listing photos. Some permits allow indoor use only. Others allow livestock, a set number of horses or a small irrigated area. I pull the permit before I write an offer, and I'd suggest you ask for it before you start picturing the barn.

Key takeaways

  • A well permit lists specific allowed uses, and those limits stay with the property when it sells.
  • On most lots under 35 acres, a standard exempt well is household use only: no lawn, garden or livestock watering.
  • Many Black Forest and Monument wells draw from the Denver Basin, where the permitted amount depends on the water under that specific parcel.
  • Permits can be out of date or in a prior owner's name. That's fixable, but it's better found before closing than at it.

Why "it has a well" isn't the whole answer

Most acreage listings in Black Forest say "well and septic" and stop there. That tells you where the water comes from, not what you're allowed to do with it.

In Colorado, every well drilled since May 8, 1972 needs a permit from the Colorado Division of Water Resources (DWR). DWR says the permit file "will contain the allowable uses of the well," along with the original application and any construction and pump records. Those allowed uses don't change because the house sold.

The surprise I see most often is with horses. A buyer assumes the property allows them, and it doesn't. Or the permit allows two horses when they were planning on three to five. Either way, it's a hard thing to learn after you've fallen for the place, and a much easier thing to learn before you write an offer.

The common permit types, in plain English

The labels vary, but most residential wells you'll run into up here fall into one of these groups.

Permit type

Usually found on

What it typically allows

What it typically doesn't

Household use only

Lots under 35 acres, permitted on or after May 8, 1972

Water used inside the home

Lawns, gardens, trees, livestock or any other outside use

Domestic and livestock

Parcels of 35 acres or more

Up to three single-family homes, up to 1 acre of lawn and garden, and livestock

More than one exempt well per parcel

Pre-1972 well

Older homes and former ranch parcels

Historic uses, up to domestic and livestock limits

Expanding beyond what was historically used

Non-exempt residential (often Denver Basin)

Lots under 35 acres where more than household use is wanted

The specific uses and amounts written on the permit, such as a number of large animals or an irrigated area

Anything not written on it

Sources: CSU Extension fact sheet 6.700, Douglas County summary of State Engineer rules.

A few details matter. Exempt wells are generally limited to 15 gallons per minute. Douglas County's summary of state rules puts household-use-only wells at up to 0.33 acre-feet a year and 35-acre domestic wells at 1 acre-foot, and notes the permit can allow less if less water is legally available under the property.

The pre-1972 row explains a common puzzle. If your neighbor's well allows livestock and the one you're looking at doesn't, the neighbor's well likely predates May 8, 1972. Grandfathered uses belong to that well, not to the neighborhood.

I grew up on one of those older parcels. It was split from a larger ranch property, and our well supported a lot: my mom was a team roper, we kept anywhere from 10 to 20 Texas Longhorns down by the riding arena, and we used every stall in a 15-stall barn. That was a different era for this area. Don't assume a newer lot carved out of the same land comes with the same water.

Why the Denver Basin changes the math up here

Much of Black Forest and the Monument area sits over the Denver Basin, a stack of deep aquifers (the Dawson, Denver, Arapahoe and Laramie-Fox Hills) that stretches from here to north of Denver. It's huge. It's also nonrenewable, which is why the rules work differently than they do for a mountain well.

Here's how the state sizes a Denver Basin permit: it estimates the water under that parcel and divides by 100 to set an annual amount, so the supply is meant to last at least 100 years. El Paso County sets a stricter 300-year standard for new development (CPR). That's why two neighboring permits can allow different amounts: acreage and the aquifers under each lot both feed the number.

Water supply concerns run deep in the forest, especially among owners with horses and livestock, and I think those concerns are fair. Water rights are bought and sold as a business, and large users want them. The state's April approval of two high-capacity Denver Basin wells for a proposed travel center near Monument Hill drew plenty of objections from neighbors for exactly that reason.

The county's own review gives useful perspective. A 2025 report to the county commissioners found water levels steady in most surveyed wells since the 1980s, with some localized dewatering and incomplete data, and the county kept its 300-year rule (The Gazette; full report).

My take: the Denver Basin isn't going anywhere, and in my experience a properly constructed well that reaches the right aquifer is in good shape. But which aquifer, how deep and how much the permit allows are questions for the permit file, the well records and a good water attorney. Not the listing.

Matching the permit to your plans

Before you tour, write down how you actually want to use the property. Then check each item against the permit's allowed uses.

  • Horses or livestock: Does the permit allow them, and how many large animals?
  • Garden, trees or a windbreak: Is any outside irrigation allowed, and how much area?
  • Lawn: On a household-use-only well, the answer is no.
  • Guest house or second home: Does the permit cover more than one dwelling? Ask DWR before you assume it does.
  • Shop or barn with water: Is a hydrant or wash rack an allowed use?
  • Pond or water feature: Usually a separate water rights question. Talk to a water attorney.

If the permit doesn't fit the plan, you have three honest options: change the plan, look at a different property, or find out with a water attorney whether a new or amended permit is realistic for that parcel. Price the third option in time and money before you count on it.

What to check before you write an offer

  1. Get the permit number. Ask the listing agent, or search DWR's Well Permit Search Tool, linked from the DWR well permitting page.
  2. Read the allowed uses. Not the summary in the listing. The actual permit language.
  3. Confirm the permit matches the well. Location, depth and aquifer on the permit should line up with what's on the ground.
  4. Check whose name is on it. It should match the seller. If it doesn't, plan time to fix it.
  5. Test the water itself. Yield and quality are inspection items. I covered those in our post on living with a well and septic.
  6. Bring in a water attorney if the permit doesn't fit your plans, or if anything above doesn't add up.

Step 4 sounds like paperwork, and usually it is. On a recent listing of mine, the sellers' well had never been properly registered to them with DWR, so there was a gap in ownership on record. To clear it, I had to walk the property to find the wellhead. DWR's location for the well put it close enough to the neighbors that it could have been a shared well serving several homes, which was common in some older neighborhoods. We were lucky: the wellhead was on their parcel and served only their home, so the fix was corrective paperwork. If it had been shared, it would have been a much bigger conversation, and not one you want to start the week of closing.

At closing, the title company typically updates the owner name on the permit through DWR's change of owner eForm. That works smoothly when the record is clean going in.

FAQ

Does a bigger lot mean more water?
Often, but not automatically. Thirty-five acres is the usual threshold for a domestic and livestock exempt well, and Denver Basin amounts depend on the water estimated under that parcel. A 34-acre lot and a 36-acre lot can carry very different permits.

What if the well was never permitted?
Wells drilled on or after May 8, 1972 need a permit; one drilled without a permit after that date was installed illegally (CSU Extension). Treat it as a serious issue and get DWR and a water attorney involved before you go further.

Can I change a household-use-only permit to allow horses?
Sometimes, depending on the parcel and the water available under it. It isn't a given, and it can take time and an attorney. Don't buy based on the assumption that you can.

Who updates the permit when I buy?
Usually the title company, at closing, through DWR's change of owner eForm. It goes smoothest when the permit is already in the seller's name.

Thinking about acreage in Black Forest or Monument?

Send me the address of a property you're watching and I'll pull the well permit and tell you what it allows, before you tour. You can reach me at 719-357-7727 or through our contact page, and see how we work with buyers on Buy with Us.

This post is general information, not water rights or legal advice. For questions about a specific well or permit, contact the Colorado Division of Water Resources or a Colorado water attorney.

Sources: Colorado Division of Water Resources · CSU Extension fact sheet 6.700 · Douglas County, State Engineer's Office info · CPR, April 2, 2026 · The Gazette, Oct. 21, 2025 · El Paso County Denver Basin report · DWR change of owner eForm

 

Check out this article next

What Is It Really Like to Live With a Well and Septic in Black Forest and Monument?

What Is It Really Like to Live With a Well and Septic in Black Forest and Monument?

It's worth knowing what you're signing up for before you fall for five acres and a barn. Here's what I've learned from living with these…

Read Article